A degree is no guarantee of a job
Posted by admin in Business and Marketing, Graphic Design From Home, graphic design on October 14th, 2008 | No Comments »A graphic design qualification lies in proof and reputation, not a piece of paper. With graphic design it’s the result that counts.
Unlike engineering or medicine, it’s not necessary for a graphic designer to attend university. While you may not want an ‘unqualified’ surgeon operating on your favourite spleen, if the logo your ‘designer’ produces is pleasing and fits all the criteria, the fact that he never graduated doesn’t come into it.
Let’s face it, clients choose a graphic designer based on what other people recommend, and what they see in a portfolio. Have you ever heard of a potential client insisting on seeing a tutor’s transcript before engaging a designer to create their new season’s catalogue?
What university training is supposed to do is ensure that a preset level of knowledge has been applied to all graduates. If you possess a degree, that means you’ve been taught about bleed, you know the law of thirds and you can brainstorm a brief.
But this knowledge is available elsewhere. And who’s to say that the student attended on the day that bleed was taught? I’ve met degree-wielding designers with no knowledge of bleed (for example). Then there is the difference between individual universities and colleges, and the abilities of their tutors, which vary tremendously. The result is that two identical students can come out with two very different educations.
University also teases the creativity out of students who might lack the confidence to utilise their skills on their own. It teaches students about deadlines, about finishing a job and about what it’s like to have your best work ripped to shreds by others. It takes stamina and determination and a thick skin to finish four years of training.
But again, a good ‘apprenticeship’ can do all that. And it’s a fact that in some training institutions there is no pressure whatsoever. I once employed a graduate from a local university with a reputation for being laid back. I had to let her go soon afterward because she simply couldn’t keep up and cracked under the pressure of the ‘real world’.
A university degree will get you an interview. But that’s about all. It’s your portfolio that lands the job. If you don’t believe me, consider the following scenario;
Two designers apply for a job. One has a degree, but a bog standard portfolio that displays little innovation and has no stand-out pieces. There are also a few mistakes in the works on display. The other applicant never attended university but has a portfolio that shines, with a mixture of highly competent examples of standard work and WOW pieces that leap off the pages.
Which one would get the job? More to the point, which one would you employ?
If you have the proof that you can do the job (portfolio) and a reputation (testimonials), you’re way ahead of someone who only has the paper (degree). Obviously if you have all three, you’re well on the way. But a degree on its own doesn’t guarantee a job.
If you’re considering entering into a multi-year training course as a means to ensure a job, but you already have a measure of skill and the proof on hand (a halfway decent portfolio), I would suggest that you save the money and time. Just start pushing that portfolio around town.
There is a lot more on this topic in my book; Get a Job in Design (ISBN 978-0-9582594-2-2), which can be found at http://www.graphic-design-jobs.com
